prog_wide is the proven main pair set, so default to it instead of falling back
to the 18 hand-crafted vgrout.pairs.PAIRS (now only reached if explicitly None).
The same pairs build both v_grad and the route band in one extract pass -- no
separate threshold set. Spec updated to say so. route2 smoke green on the new
default (band +0.259). erase unaffected (explicit --v-hack-path takes precedence).
Co-Authored-By: Claudypoo <288921227+claudypoo@users.noreply.github.com>
Fresh-eyes review flagged that nothing asserted upper>lower for the REAL
v_grad: a broken extraction (hack pairs aligning no more than clean) would
silently degenerate into the random-control sign gate via the max(.,1e-6)
floor. Assert mean band width > 0 on non-Haar runs; the Haar control is still
allowed to collapse. No correctness change to the gate math (review found
conservation, per-rollout recovery, cosine masking, closure capture all OK).
Co-Authored-By: Claudypoo <288921227+claudypoo@users.noreply.github.com>
Replace the confounded route2 gate (hack_anchor force-routed teacher +
weak-detector student rows by LABEL; EMA tau calibrated from a live detector
over student rollouts at train time = a cheat) with a band calibrated from the
contrastive pairs alone:
lower = mean clean-pair cos(g, v_grad); upper = mean hack-pair cos
per rollout: f = clamp((cos(g_b, v_grad) - lower)/(upper - lower), 0, 1)
routed = sum_b f_b * g_b -> delta_S_hack; kept = g - routed -> delta_S
v_grad is now the SOLE router: no detector or gt_pass touches routing, so
"does v_hack generalize to held-out modes" is clean and random-vs-real is
decisive. Band width (upper-lower) is itself the discriminator: smoke shows
+0.289 real vs -0.014 Haar-random (collapsed). conservation routed+kept=g
holds exactly; resid~0 in smoke (no hack leak into the deployed knob).
- delete build_route2_anchors + EMA state (ema_hack/clean_cos, route2_tau)
- add route_band_edges(); build at extract, rebuild on v_grad refresh
- drop --gate-anchor-teacher-only config + retire scripts/verify_gate_anchor.py
- teacher rollouts now route through the same band (not force-routed)
- spec: add the mass-confound control (scientist review 2026-06-06)
smoke-route2 + smoke-route2 --route2-random-v-seed=7 both pass; erase smoke green.
Co-Authored-By: Claudypoo <288921227+claudypoo@users.noreply.github.com>
The 'weak detector for hack A, generalize to B' framing was wrong for this repo.
That is the weak-LABEL setup (labelA -> labelNotA), which is NOT ours. Ours is
vec -> routing: vec extracted from hand-built synthetic pairs, route the live
GRPO gradient by cosine alignment to vec; no detector ever runs over student
rollouts at train time. Generalization = does vec (from pairs covering some
modes) suppress held-out modes -- vector generalization, not detector-label.
- AGENTS.md: rewrote the no-cheat bullet to the 3-way distinction (oracle grader
= cheat; weak-label setup = not ours; vec->routing = ours). For coding agents.
- README: removed the 'We cannot cheat' section (belongs in agent instructions,
not the new-reader overview).
- spec: dropped the stray 'validation uses known-A detector' line; pointed the
no-cheat reference at AGENTS.md.
Co-Authored-By: Claudypoo <288921227+claudypoo@users.noreply.github.com>
Validation removed: running the weak detector over student rollouts at train
time is the no-cheat violation, and a live validation is complex/non-causal.
Causal proof stays downstream (deploy perf + real-vs-random). Train-time only
LOGs label-free gauges: hkgap=upper-lower, leave-one-pair-out separation (the
'does the threshold generalize to a second pair' test), live cos_b percentiles
vs [lower,upper] (calibration read with no labels), route_frac mass at 0/1,
resid=cos(g_keep,vec).
Granularity decided = per-rollout: train.py already sums per-token gate grads
to [G,r] and recovers g_b=cg/dS per rollout; band just swaps the cos_b>tau line
for the ramp. Backed by the papers: Gradient Routing (Cloud 2024) masks
per-token for LLMs / per-episode for RL; SGTM (2025) per-example, label-noise-
robust. Both route by a DATA-LABEL mask; we route by gradient ALIGNMENT to an
extracted direction -- that's the novelty. Borrow their 'absorption' as the
mechanism justifying A->B generalization.
Co-Authored-By: Claudypoo <288921227+claudypoo@users.noreply.github.com>
Replaces the single-midpoint tau with a two-edge band: x=cos(g_step,vec),
route_frac=clamp((x-lower)/(upper-lower),0,1). lower=mean cos(g_cho,vec),
upper=mean cos(g_rej,vec). Below lower keep, above upper route, between =
absorption (proportional split). Band WIDTH (hkgap=upper-lower) is the
real-vs-random discriminator (random vec closes the band) so no separate
matched-fraction control is needed; collapse flags vec degeneracy.
Calibration validation on live KNOWN-mode-A rollouts (detector-labelled, no-cheat):
mean route_frac(A_hack) >> mean route_frac(A_clean) confirms the pair-set band
transfers to the sampled live distribution. Also picks g_step granularity
(per-rollout default vs per-step). Held-out B never in validation.
Corrects the earlier wrong claim that component-routing collapses to erase
(pseudocode 03 route v1 forward uses dS+dS_hack -> divergent trajectory).
Co-Authored-By: Claudypoo <288921227+claudypoo@users.noreply.github.com>
External review (Claude + deepseek-v4-pro) converged on the threshold being
circular (c_rej>c_cho holds by construction since vec=mean(g_rej-g_cho)) plus
scale-mismatched to live rollouts. Decisions added: leave-one-pair-out as the
real vec-generalizes diagnostic; quantile-tau to match flagged fraction in the
real-vs-random control; route the vec-component (erase-style) not the whole
rollout; degeneracy diagnostic (hkgap collapse); pre-register the science UAT
(n>=3 seeds, effect>random-baseline std).
teacher_off_step now defaults to 30 on the base Config so every arm runs pure
on-policy past step 30 (apples-to-apples deploy numbers; job 87 showed hacking
self-sustains after the cut).
Co-Authored-By: Claudypoo <288921227+claudypoo@users.noreply.github.com>
Adds actionable train.py targets (delete build_route2_anchors, rewrite
_route2_grad_filter to pure cos>tau gate, pair-calibrated tau refreshed every N,
teacher_off_step=30), current state (queue PAUSED, on main, rollback tag), queued-job
disposition (superseded vs keep), and smoke/UAT. Self-contained handoff for post-compact.
Co-Authored-By: Claudypoo <288921227+claudypoo@users.noreply.github.com>
wassname