wassname ffe206bb55 paper-review pass on lab report: annotated + review files ...

Phase 1: 25 inline annotations on docs/lab/...partial_n3.md, covering
preregistration gaps (n=2 vs SEM clause; 21 pairs vs preregistered 60-80;
pass-rate at 10pp boundary), Adam-momentum projection leak, cosine-vs-null
baseline, mixed-pool training caveat, Appendix B step-0-hack-detector
inconsistency, refresh compute cost, and a few smaller items (mix_ratio
semantics, K_axes value, AntiPaSTO module count).

Phase 2: review file with strengths, weaknesses, per-section comments,
questions, and a four-tier accept criterion. Current verdict: weak accept
as internal lab report, major revision as public draft.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 <noreply@anthropic.com>

2026-05-29 03:24:20 +00:00

..

projected_grpo-2026-05-29-lab-n3.annotated.md

paper-review pass on lab report: annotated + review files

2026-05-29 03:24:20 +00:00

projected_grpo-2026-05-29-lab-n3.md

paper-review pass on lab report: annotated + review files

2026-05-29 03:24:20 +00:00

projected_grpo-2026-05-29-lab-n3.review.md

paper-review pass on lab report: annotated + review files

2026-05-29 03:24:20 +00:00