scrape_r_rational/data/cache2/7rhyo1.md

[REC] Rationalist Naruto Fanfiction

• Author: u/None *

• URL: https://www.reddit.com/r/rational/comments/7rhyo1/rec_rationalist_naruto_fanfiction/

• Score: 4

• Created: 2018-01-19T12:22:45

Post:

I really enjoyed (some) of the rational(ist) Naruto fanfiction I've read, and I'm seeking recommendations. Stories I like(d) (in approximate order of desirability):

1. Lighting up the Dark (I greatly enjoyed this, and love the concept (superintelligent tailed beasts, smart!Cast, etc), excluding the increased intelligence, I think the author stuck to the canon characterisation (which is more than I can say for most fanfics. I might rate this above HPMOR).
2. Need to Become Stronger
3. Scorpion's Disciple
4. Chasing the Shadow (Fem!Haku)

 
Stories I disliked:

1. The Waves Arisen: The story was definitely rationalist, but it's fanfiction and along the way it started treating characters I liked poorly. After reading it, I stayed away from all rational(ist) fanfiction until someone recommended Scorpion's Disciple to me.

 
Stories I haven't yet/wouldn't read:

1. Time Braid: I dislike Sakura, and don't want to read a story where she's the MC (rationalist or not). Reading it feels like a chore and isn't hedonistic (this may be due to my reluctance to start stories with female MCs (and I have much less patience in fanfiction).
2. Roll the Dice on Fate: first person doesn't sit well with me in regards to fanfiction, I read it for the established characters, and if I self insert, it's into established characters.
3. Marked for Death: I dislike original characters, first person, CYOA, etc in my fanfiction, again, I read fanfics only for the established characters.

 
I would appreciate it if recommendations are above 100 K words of written content.

Comments:

u/blazinghand [+7] Chaos Undivided (5 hours later)

EagleJarl's Team Anko is Naruto Rational Fanfiction: https://www.fanfiction.net/s/11087425/1/Team-Anko

(AU) [Rationality, meet Naruto] - Anko never wanted to lead a genin team. Sadly, the Hokage isn't okay with that; he hands her Naruto, Hinata, and Shino and orders her to "make them the best ninja and, more importantly, the best people possible." She's got her work cut out for her. M for combat and occasional cursing.

164k words, complete. Naruto is the MC but there is another character who really shines here.

Many people liked it. Could be worth investigating.

u/ToaKraka [+4] https://i.imgur.com/OQGHleQ.png (5 hours later)

OP wants stories that stick to canon characterizations. IIRC, Team Anko completely eviscerates Shino.

u/blazinghand [+2] Chaos Undivided (7 hours later)

Given that he tolerated the characterization of certain characters in Lighting Up The Dark, I think Team Anko might well be up his alley. Certainly Naruto is more canonically characterized in Team Anko than he is in Lighting Up The Dark by a huge amount. So, it's worth a shot for him.

u/EthanCC [+2] (a day later)

IMO Team Anko turns Orochimaru into a villain sue, by making him a bit too moral among other things I picked up on in the narrative (it was one of those death of a thousand cuts situations where I can't really point to one thing). The hypercompetency I can understand since he's supposed to be at the absolute top of a very competitive profession in canon, but it confuses me how he seems to genuinely care about his people when there's no need to act despite being stated to have some sort of antisocial personality disorder, and at other times ot showing any empathy. Otherwise it was pretty enjoyable.

u/eaglejarl [+10] (2 days later)

He

u/None [+1] (19 hours later)

Will give it a try.

u/paradoxinclination [+5] (9 hours later)

I'm not sure it's exactly rational- it might be rationalist -but People Lie by Nugar is pretty great. Good fight scenes and characterization, with some weird Lovecraftian elements tossed in for fun.

u/None [+2] (19 hours later)

Will give it a try.

u/None [+2] (a day later)

People Lie was excellent. Unfortunately abandoned though.

u/GeeJo [+4] Custom Flair (an hour later)

Try out Chiaroscuro, if you haven't.

u/None [+2] (19 hours later)

It's great, however adjusting to it was difficult. I was so used to smart Naruto, that I forgot why I rated the original Naruto series as a B-rate anime in the first place. Adjusting to dumb Naruto, and getting used to Shikamaru was a different experience. I intend on finishing it though.

u/serge_cell [+3] (4 hours later)

I wouldnt qualify Need to become stronger as truly rational fiction. It has some qualities of rational fiction but missing the first - nothing happens because plot require it. Most glaring are long, high intencity fights where no one important is killed.

u/None [+2] (19 hours later)

The author definitely tried to make it rationalist—whether they succeeded is something else (IIRC the Wave people died like flies).

u/Chimerasame [+3] (6 days later)

Time Braid: I dislike Sakura, and don't want to read a story where she's the MC (rationalist or not). Reading it feels like a chore and isn't hedonistic (this may be due to my reluctance to start stories with female MCs (and I have much less patience in fanfiction).

If it helps, the characterization of Time Braid Sakura is very different from the characterization of canon Sakura. She kind of starts out the same way, but changes fast.

Out of curiosity, why the antipathy towards female MCs? Do the authors you've tried out thus far just write them differently? Or is it something more than that, like just simply knowing they're female makes it harder to identify with or something?

u/None [+2] (8 days later)

Well I recently read Lavender Clouds (MC is Hinata), and I really, really enjoyed it (much more than I expected to (the grammar is horrendous)), even crying at times). I thought it might be because knowing they're female makes them harder to identify with (and the situation with Lavender clouds is very rare), I still think it is, but seeing as I could empathise with Hinata (though not fully insert myself as her (I usually inserted from the POV of the male characters she interacted with)) I think how the author writes them affects my enjoyment. I now believe that I simply cannot self insert in female characters though (this isn't the same as identifying with a character (which I can do)).
 
Time Braid sounds like something I'll read because I should read it, not because I'll enjoy it. Sakura as an MC is a problem (I have trouble with Chiaroscuro because Shikamaru is the MC). Excluding the fact I can't self insert in female characters, I dislike Sakura as a character, and reading her as MC (even with a different personality) is not something I want to do).

u/None [+1] (a day later)

[deleted]

u/None [+2] (a day later)

Not my recollection of Time Braid. It did have some smut, but not excessive (IMO).

---